Festive Desserts Without Refined Sugar: Dates, Maple, Coconut

Date purée, a drizzle of maple syrup and a spoonful of coconut sugar are all free sugars, in exactly the same category as white sugar. That is the definition used by the NHS and by the World Health Organization, and it explicitly puts syrups and fruit purées alongside added sugar. Swapping refined sugar for these three ingredients changes the flavour, the texture and a little of the mineral content. It does not lower the amount of sugar in the dessert.

Everything below starts from that. The three recipes further down are weighed, and their composition is calculated ingredient by ingredient, because that is the only way to know what you are serving. Two squares of the date brownie carry 28 grams of sugars, which is close to an adult’s daily reference figure. One glass of the coconut panna cotta carries 17.5 grams of saturated fat, which is more than its sugar content. These are festive desserts and they behave like festive desserts.

What “no refined sugar” means, and what it does not mean

The phrase describes a process, not a nutritional profile. White sugar is extracted from beet or cane and then purified until almost nothing but sucrose remains. Dates, maple syrup and coconut sugar arrive on the plate carrying a small fraction of what surrounded them in the plant: minerals, phenolic compounds, sometimes fibre.

That fraction is real and it is measurable. It is also small, and it travels with a great deal of sugar. This is the part that lists of benefits almost always skip. A mineral present at a few milligrams per 100 grams of an ingredient you eat 20 grams of does not move the needle across a day of eating. The arithmetic appears below for each of the three.

One difference does matter, and it is technical rather than nutritional. These three sweeteners have a flavour. White sugar has almost none. A batter sweetened with date purée has a caramelised depth that sucrose does not give, and that sometimes lets you cut the total quantity because the dessert reads as more interesting at the same sweetness. That is a cook’s lever, not a health argument.

Free sugars: the only category the health guidance uses

The NHS defines free sugars as sugars added to food or drink, plus the sugars naturally present in honey, syrups, nectars, unsweetened fruit and vegetable juices, smoothies and purées. Sugars found naturally in milk, whole fruit and vegetables do not count.

That boundary places the three ingredients in this article unevenly.

Maple syrup and coconut sugar are free sugars with no room for argument. One is a syrup, the other is a crystallised sugar sold to sweeten things.

The date is subtler. A whole date, eaten as it comes, is a dried fruit and its sugars are not free sugars. The same date soaked and blended into a paste becomes a fruit purée, and its sugars move into the free sugar column. The very step that makes a date usable in baking is the step that changes its status. It feels counter-intuitive and it is nonetheless the plain reading of the official definition.

The daily free sugar figures published by the NHS are 30 grams for an adult, 24 grams for children aged 7 to 10, 19 grams for ages 4 to 6, 14 grams for ages 2 to 3 and 10 grams at age one. Below one year, no sugar should be added to food or drink at all.

The WHO puts the same idea as a percentage: less than 10% of total energy intake, which works out at roughly 50 grams on a 2,000 kilocalorie diet, with further benefit expected below 5%. The same fact sheet asks for at least 25 grams of dietary fibre a day for everyone over ten, a figure worth holding on to when we get to the fibre content of dates.

If the wider question of alternative sweeteners interests you, our guide to natural sugar alternatives and GI compares a broader range, and our piece on natural sugars: date, maple, lucuma goes further into the individual ingredients.

How much sugar people in Switzerland actually eat

The Federal Food Safety and Veterinary Office estimates, from Agristat consumption data for 2023, that the Swiss population takes in roughly 90 grams of sugar per person per day. That is close to double the WHO figure of 50 grams.

It is also why the federal government works with industry rather than with consumers alone. The Milan Declaration commits Swiss manufacturers and retailers to reducing sugar in their products voluntarily. The fifth round table took place on 21 August 2025, and twenty-one companies signed the text again, with targets running to the end of 2028: minus 5% for yoghurt, minus 10% for quark, breakfast cereals, soft drinks and flavoured milk drinks. Over ten years, sugar in drinks has come down by 13%.

That context gives a festive dessert its proper scale. A date brownie served three or four times a year weighs nothing in an annual average. A daily sweetened yoghurt weighs a great deal. The occasion and the habit are different problems, and precisely because festive desserts are occasional, it makes more sense to cook them well than to cook them diet. If it is the habit you want to change, a 30-day no added sugar challenge tackles it from the right end.

Dates: the most interesting of the three, with one condition

What the composition says

The USDA database gives, per 100 grams of Medjool dates, 277 kilocalories, 74.97 grams of carbohydrate of which 33.68 grams glucose, 31.95 grams fructose and 0.53 grams sucrose, 6.7 grams of fibre, 696 milligrams of potassium, 64 milligrams of calcium, 54 milligrams of magnesium and 0.9 milligrams of iron.

The Deglet Noor variety, drier and more common in Swiss shops, comes in at 282 kilocalories, 8 grams of fibre and a strikingly different sugar profile: 23.84 grams of sucrose against 19.87 grams of glucose and 19.56 grams of fructose. That difference has a practical consequence. A Medjool, rich in simple sugars and water, blends into a smooth paste. A Deglet Noor, drier and more fibrous, needs a longer soak and gives a grainier purée.

Three Medjool dates weigh about 72 grams. They supply 501 milligrams of potassium, roughly a quarter of the nutrient reference value, and 4.8 grams of fibre, close to a fifth of the WHO daily figure. They also supply 47.6 grams of sugars. The fibre and potassium are genuine; they are inseparable from the sugar load.

Glycaemic index, with the actual numbers

The claim that dates have a low glycaemic index is everywhere. The data exists and it is more nuanced than the claim.

A trial published in the Annals of Saudi Medicine in 2016 measured the glycaemic index and glycaemic load of seventeen date varieties in nineteen healthy subjects, each receiving 50 grams of available carbohydrate. The mean glycaemic index was 55.2 with a standard error of 7.7, and the range ran from 42.8 for the Shaqra variety to 74.6 for Sellaj. Glycaemic load spanned 8.5 to 24 depending on the variety.

So the mean does sit in the low to moderate band, but the spread between varieties is wider than the gap between an average date and a good many other sweet foods. A later study published in 2021 in Diabetes Research and Clinical Practice, using continuous glucose monitoring in twenty people with type 2 diabetes and twenty matched controls, found no significant difference in mean glycaemic index between the groups, though it did find a difference in the timing of the glucose peak across varieties.

What that licenses: dates sit on average in the low to moderate range. What it does not licence: announcing a low glycaemic index as a general property of dates, without naming the variety.

Date purée: the method that works

Use 250 grams of pitted dates to 150 millilitres of hot water. Soak for 20 minutes for Medjool, 40 minutes for dry Deglet Noor. Blend with the soaking water until smooth. You end up with roughly 380 grams of purée at about 45 grams of sugars per 100 grams.

This purée replaces sugar in wet preparations: brownies, moist cakes, porridge, fillings. It does not replace sugar in anything that depends on crystallisation, and the technical section below explains why.

It keeps five days in the fridge in a clean jar, and it freezes well in spoonfuls dropped onto a tray. Our raw desserts with dates and cocoa use the same paste with no oven involved.

Maple syrup: sucrose, with manganese attached

Maple syrup is made by concentrating the sap of the sugar maple. It takes roughly forty litres of sap to make one litre of syrup, which explains both the price and the concentration.

The USDA gives, per 100 grams of maple syrup: 260 kilocalories, 67.04 grams of carbohydrate of which 58.32 grams sucrose, 1.6 grams glucose and 0.52 grams fructose, no fibre, 2.908 milligrams of manganese, 1.47 milligrams of zinc, 102 milligrams of calcium and 212 milligrams of potassium.

Manganese is the one figure that stands out. A 20 gram tablespoon delivers 0.58 milligrams of manganese, roughly 29% of the European nutrient reference value of 2 milligrams. That is objectively a lot for a sweetener. It is also a nutrient whose deficiency is practically unheard of on an ordinary diet, vegetarian ones included, because wholegrains, pulses and tea supply it generously. Extra manganese solves no existing problem.

The other minerals amount to nothing at tablespoon scale: 0.29 milligrams of zinc, about 3% of the reference value, and 20 milligrams of calcium, about 2.5%.

What remains is flavour, and there maple syrup is hard to replace. Its woody, vanilla notes come from compounds formed during evaporation, not from the sap itself. A dark syrup tapped late in the season has a far more pronounced profile than a light early-season one, and it is the dark grade you want when the syrup has to make itself heard in a bake.

Three practical points in the kitchen. Syrup brings liquid, so remove roughly 60 millilitres of other liquid for every 100 millilitres of syrup used. It browns faster than sucrose because it contains free glucose and fructose that feed Maillard reactions, so drop the oven by ten degrees. And it acidifies the batter slightly, which can make any bicarbonate of soda in the recipe work harder.

Coconut sugar: the most argued-over glycaemic index and the least documented

Coconut sugar comes from the sap of coconut palm inflorescences, heated until it crystallises. A review published in 2023 in the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health describes the process in detail and lets several marketing claims be put back in proportion.

On yield first. A coconut palm typically produces one inflorescence a month. Sap collected twice a day contains around 15 grams of sugar per 100 grams, which allows roughly 200 grams of sugar per inflorescence per day. Each tapping means cutting one to two millimetres off the spadix, so a single spadix can be tapped for forty to forty-five days, and a tree for around twenty years. It is slow manual work, and the price shows it: the same review records a cost between 15 and 46 euros per kilo, against 0.88 euros for refined sugar in 2021.

On composition next. The analyses cited do not agree with one another. One gas chromatography study finds 83.18 to 90.50 grams of sucrose per 100 grams in coconut sugar; another finds 49.41 to 57.05 grams depending on whether the sap was kept with or without a preservative. The review also reports an inulin content of 4.7 grams per 100 grams, a fermentable compound that explains part of the interest in this sugar.

On glycaemic index last, which is the central selling point. The review reports a range of 35 to 54 per serving, attributed to work by Trinidad and colleagues, and a value of 35 for the sap. That is low, and it is also a wide range from a limited number of measurements. A 2026 review of low glycaemic index carbohydrates in energy bars separately reports bars formulated with coconut sugar landing in the low fifties, which points the same way without independently confirming it.

One further point deserves to be known, because it never appears on packaging. The brown colour of coconut sugar and syrup comes from caramelisation and Maillard reactions, which also produce acrylamide and hydroxymethylfurfural. A study cited by the review measured 867 micrograms of acrylamide per kilogram in coconut syrup, while the compound was not detected in the raw sap. The review also notes that research on other contaminants in coconut sugar, meaning heavy metals, pesticide residues and mycotoxins, is almost non-existent. None of that is a reason to avoid coconut sugar in a festive dessert. It is a reason not to present it as inherently safer than white sugar.

In the kitchen, coconut sugar substitutes for brown sugar weight for weight. Its sweetening power is slightly lower, its caramel flavour is pronounced, and its crystals are coarser than caster sugar, which is a problem in a meringue or a fine shortcrust. Ten seconds in a spice grinder fixes that.

What sugar actually does in a batter, beyond tasting sweet

This is the chapter most substitution articles leave out, and it is the one that explains why the recipes fail.

A review published in Food Research International in 2019 sets out the functions of sugar in baked goods. Sugar raises the gelatinisation temperature of starch. It delays gluten network development. It changes yeast activity depending on concentration. It enhances emulsification. It supports the aeration of cake batter, which is what produces the characteristic soft crumb. It drives browning reactions. It lowers water activity and so extends microbial shelf life. In biscuits, it governs spread during baking and causes the surface cracking that comes from recrystallisation.

None of those effects depends on sweetness. They depend on sucrose crystals being present, on their size, and on how much water they tie up.

That dictates three substitution rules.

Date purée works in preparations where you want moistness and where the structure comes from something other than sugar: dense brownies, oil-based cakes, muffins, bars. It brings water and fibre, so the batter will be wetter and tighter.

Maple syrup works anywhere a sweet liquid is not a problem: custards, set creams, glazes, fruit macerations, pancake batter. It does not work in a biscuit that has to stay crisp, because it holds moisture in.

Coconut sugar is the only one of the three that behaves roughly like white sugar, because it is crystalline. It is therefore the one to reach for in shortbread, cut-out biscuits, or any dough that has to spread in the oven.

Our egg-free baking guide applies the same reasoning to binders, and the gluten-free flour guide does the same for structure.

Three weighed recipes, with their composition

The compositions below are calculated ingredient by ingredient from USDA tables and standard reference values for dry goods. They describe the recipe as written; changing the brand of plant milk or the size of the dates moves the figures by a few per cent.

Date and walnut brownie

For a 20 by 20 centimetre tin, 12 squares of about 55 grams.

  • 250 g pitted Medjool dates
  • 150 ml hot water for soaking
  • 120 g wholemeal or light wholemeal flour
  • 30 g unsweetened cocoa powder
  • 80 g walnut pieces
  • 30 g neutral oil or mild olive oil
  • 150 ml unsweetened almond milk
  • a pinch of salt

Soak the dates for 20 minutes in the hot water, then blend them with their water until smooth. Stir in the oil and the almond milk. Add the flour, cocoa and salt, mix without working the batter, then fold in the walnuts. Pour into a lined tin and bake at 175 degrees for 22 to 26 minutes. The centre should still be slightly wet coming out of the oven; it firms up as it cools.

Per 55 gram square: about 165 kilocalories, 3.0 g protein, 24.7 g carbohydrate of which 14.2 g sugars, 7.5 g fat of which 1.0 g saturates, and 3.3 g fibre.

Two squares carry 28.4 grams of sugars. The adult daily free sugar figure is 30 grams. That is the number to know before you set the whole tray down, and it is also why this brownie should be cut small.

Coconut and maple panna cotta

For 4 glasses of about 165 grams.

  • 400 ml full-fat coconut milk
  • 45 ml dark maple syrup
  • 2 g powdered agar-agar
  • 200 g fresh or frozen berries
  • 15 ml maple syrup for the coulis

Whisk the agar-agar into the cold coconut milk, add the 45 millilitres of syrup, bring to a full rolling boil and hold for one minute while stirring. Agar-agar only sets if it has genuinely boiled. Pour into glasses and chill for at least two hours. Cook the berries down for ten minutes with the remaining 15 millilitres of syrup, cool completely, then spoon over the set panna cotta.

Per glass: about 260 kilocalories, 2.5 g protein, 17.0 g carbohydrate of which 15.1 g sugars, 20.2 g fat of which 17.5 g saturates, and 2.5 g fibre.

This dessert contains more saturated fat than sugar, and the next section explains why that is the decisive figure here. For control over the set, our article on agar-agar and pectin covers dosage according to the acidity of the mixture.

Festive coconut sugar biscuits

For about 30 biscuits of 16 grams.

  • 250 g light wholemeal flour
  • 80 g coconut sugar, finely ground
  • 60 g melted coconut oil
  • 80 ml unsweetened plant milk
  • 1 teaspoon cinnamon
  • 1 teaspoon mixed spice
  • a pinch of salt

Mix the dry ingredients, rub in the melted coconut oil with your fingertips, then add the plant milk a little at a time until you have a smooth dough that no longer sticks. Chill for 30 minutes, roll out to 5 millimetres, cut out shapes and bake at 175 degrees for 10 to 12 minutes. The biscuits are soft out of the oven and harden as they cool.

Per 16 gram biscuit: about 57 kilocalories, 1.0 g protein, 8.2 g carbohydrate of which 2.5 g sugars, 2.2 g fat of which 1.7 g saturates, and 0.5 g fibre.

This is the most restrained of the three recipes, because sugar here is one ingredient among several rather than the base of the dessert. Three biscuits carry 7.5 grams of sugars.

Coconut milk is the real nutritional problem in these desserts

The NHS sets a reference of 30 grams of saturated fat a day for men and 20 grams for women, and explicitly lists coconut oil and coconut cream among the plant sources high in saturates.

One glass of the panna cotta above carries 17.5 grams. That is 88% of an adult woman’s daily figure, in a single dessert. The 15 grams of sugars in the same glass are, next to that, a detail.

This imbalance is invisible in a recipe written without a composition, and it is exactly the sort of thing an article about sugar overlooks because it is looking elsewhere. There are two ways to fix it. Replacing half the coconut milk with an oat or soya drink halves the saturates and gives a lighter panna cotta, at the cost of a less rich texture. Serving 80 gram glasses instead of 165 gram ones fixes it without touching the recipe, and it is closer to what actually gets served at the end of a festive meal.

What you are allowed to put on a label in Switzerland

This matters beyond manufacturers. It gives you the legal thresholds for judging a product you buy and for naming correctly what you make.

Annex 13 of the Swiss ordinance on food information sets three claims that are relevant here. A food is “low in sugars” if it contains no more than 5 grams of sugars per 100 grams for a solid, or 2.5 grams per 100 millilitres for a liquid. It is “sugar-free” if it contains no more than 0.5 grams per 100 grams or 100 millilitres. And it is “with no added sugars” only if no monosaccharide or disaccharide has been added, and if no other foodstuff used for its sweetening properties has been added either. Where sugars are naturally present, the label must carry the wording “contains naturally occurring sugars”.

Hold the three recipes against those thresholds. The brownie runs at 25.8 grams of sugars per 100 grams, the panna cotta at 9.1 and the biscuits at 16.2. None comes anywhere near the 5 grams needed for “low in sugars”.

The third criterion is sharper still. Date purée is a foodstuff used for its sweetening properties. A cake sweetened with dates therefore cannot carry “no added sugars” in Switzerland, even if it contains not one gram of white sugar. The very common formula “no added sugar, sweetened with dates only” is self-contradictory under Swiss law. The same reasoning applies to maple syrup and to coconut sugar.

Sugar, teeth and dried fruit

The NHS links tooth decay to the frequency of sugar exposure and to the action of dental plaque rather than to a single quantity. On that measure, a festive dessert eaten at the table at the end of a meal is in the most favourable configuration available: one episode, alongside other food, followed by brushing.

The case of dried fruit deserves a closer look, because the advice to eat it only at mealtimes rests on thinner ground than most people assume. A review published in 2016 in the International Journal of Food Sciences and Nutrition concludes that the common perceptions that dried fruits are sticky, adhere to teeth and harm dental health through their sugar content are based on weak evidence, and that good quality data to support restrictive advice is lacking. The authors also point to potentially favourable attributes that have not been studied seriously: chewing dried fruit encourages salivary flow, and dried fruit contains sorbitol and antimicrobial compounds.

A scientific workshop held in the UK and published in 2019 in the same journal reached a comparable view while flagging the conflicts in public health messaging about dried fruit.

The practical conclusion is modest: nothing obliges you to treat a date like a sweet, and nothing lets you treat it as neutral for teeth either. Brushing twice a day with fluoride toothpaste remains the measure with the largest effect.

Safety points worth knowing

Four concrete points, none of them theoretical.

Below one year, no sugar should be added to food or drink, date purée included. The NHS guidance is explicit on this.

Whole dates are a choking risk for young children because of their size and sticky texture, and the stone must be removed with certainty before any blending. A forgotten stone will break a blender and, more seriously, end up in the batter.

The walnuts in the brownie fall under allergen labelling if you are giving the tray away. Tree nuts are among the allergens that must be declared, and a handwritten note on the box does the job.

Agar-agar must boil to set. A panna cotta that does not set is almost always one that never reached a full rolling boil, or one with very acidic fruit added before the gel formed.

Five mistakes that keep coming back

Replacing sugar with date purée weight for weight, without correcting the liquids. The purée is around 40% water. Swapped gram for gram, the batter becomes too wet and the cake does not bake through. Take out 60 millilitres of liquid for every 100 grams of purée.

Using maple syrup in a biscuit that has to be crisp. The syrup holds moisture, the biscuit stays soft and softens further within 24 hours. Coconut sugar is the right choice here.

Leaning on glycaemic index to justify quantity. A low glycaemic index describes the speed of absorption, not the load. The glycaemic load of dates measured in the 2016 trial runs from 8.5 to 24 depending on the variety, and 24 is not a low value.

Adding up benefits while ignoring the serving size. The potassium in dates and the manganese in maple syrup are real in the composition table. Scaled to the tablespoon or the two squares actually eaten, only manganese passes 10% of a reference value, and it is the one of the two you are least likely to need.

Writing “no added sugar” on a dessert sweetened with dates. That wording contradicts point 19 of Annex 13 of the Swiss food information ordinance directly.

Adapting to different situations

For type 2 diabetes, the useful parameter is the carbohydrate content of the portion, not the nature of the sweetener. One brownie square carries 24.7 grams of carbohydrate, one panna cotta glass 17 grams and one biscuit 8.2 grams. Those figures count like any other carbohydrate and belong in a conversation with whoever manages the treatment.

For a child aged four to six, the free sugar reference is 19 grams a day. One brownie square carries 14.2 of them, which leaves little room for the rest of the day. A biscuit at 2.5 grams is a far better fit for a children’s table.

For an already rich festive meal, full-fat coconut panna cotta duplicates a creamy starter and a fatty main. Cutting to 80 gram glasses, or replacing part of the coconut milk with a plant drink, solves the problem without changing the dessert.

For a tight budget, Deglet Noor dates cost considerably less than Medjool and give a perfectly usable purée after a longer soak. Coconut sugar is the most expensive of the three sweeteners per kilo and the easiest to swap for brown cane sugar in a biscuit recipe.

For a nut-free table, the walnuts in the brownie can be replaced weight for weight with toasted pumpkin seeds. Our festive menus without soya or nuts give further equivalences.

What this article does not settle

No environmental footprint comparison is offered here between beet sugar, imported dates, Canadian maple syrup and Southeast Asian coconut sugar. The available life cycle assessments do not use the same boundaries and do not support an honest ranking. What is documented and cited above is the yield of coconut sap tapping and the price gap with refined sugar.

The glycaemic index of coconut sugar rests on a limited number of measurements, the main one of which has not been independently reproduced. The range of 35 to 54 is reported here as published, with that limitation attached.

The compositions of the three recipes are calculated from composition tables, not measured in a laboratory. They give the right order of magnitude and the right hierarchy between nutrients, to within a few per cent.

Frequently asked questions

Is date purée really as sugary as white sugar? Not weight for weight: the purée runs at about 45 grams of sugars per 100 grams against 100 for white sugar. But you use more of it to reach the same sweetness, and its sugars count as free sugars all the same.

Is coconut sugar suitable for people with diabetes? It is not a special food for diabetes. Its published glycaemic index sits between 35 and 54, which is low, but the carbohydrate content of the portion remains the decisive parameter and the number of available measurements is small.

Can maple syrup be replaced with agave syrup? Yes for texture, no for flavour. Agave is higher in fructose and more neutral. Both count as free sugars. Our plant-based honey alternatives set out the substitution ratios.

How long do these desserts keep? The brownie holds four days in the fridge in a closed box and freezes in squares. The panna cotta keeps three days chilled and does not freeze: agar-agar turns grainy after thawing. The biscuits keep two weeks in an airtight tin, provided they have cooled completely before being put away.

Should you reduce the total quantity when switching to natural sweeteners? That is the one move that genuinely changes the composition. Cutting the sweetener by a third goes almost unnoticed in a cocoa brownie, where the bitterness of the cocoa and the salt carry the flavour. It is noticed immediately in a panna cotta, where the sweetener has nothing to hide behind.

Does coconut sugar taste of coconut? No. It is made from the sap of the flowers, not from the nut. It tastes of light caramel, close to a muscovado.

Can these recipes be made without an oven? The brownie and the biscuits need baking. For a festive table with no oven, our no-bake vegan desserts rely on setting in the cold and on the same sweeteners.

Do these desserts fit a local Swiss festive menu? Dates, maple syrup and coconut sugar are all imported. If provenance is a criterion, our Swiss locavore Christmas table starts from Swiss honey, pears and dried apples, which are still free sugars but travel a great deal less far.

Sources